Check Engine Light Causing Woes at Inspections Stations

Reported by: Mike Matthews
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 2/21/2012 6:17 pm
MEMPHIS, TN (abc24.com) - The check engine light in your car is causing lots of problems in Memphis. Since last fall if the engine light is on, the car must be repaired before being inspected.

The cost of repairs can be hundreds of dollars, and there are people who say they can't afford to keep their car on the roads because of the changes. The people in charge of inspections say tough, it's the law.

One of the joys of living in Memphis is once a year you take the old girl down to get inspected. We're talking about your car, of course.

Sometimes she creaks and moans, sometimes she sputters, most time she gets a thumbs up. But since last fall, they won't approve your car if the check engine light is on.

Melvin Parker owns a garage directly across the street from the downtown inspection station. He sees lights every day, about 10 a week, he says. He also says it's pretty expensive to fix.

A check engine light could mean a lot of things, and many times it has nothing to do with the cars emission system. And that's the point; the computer system used at inspection stations replaces the old emissions check.

Thank the feds for that, by the way. According to Public Services Director Janet Hooks, the city is mandated to do inspections this way. She told city council members that the inspection changes have been ordered because the Memphis air is often dirtier than the Mississippi River.

The trouble is, Memphis is the only place that is forced to do these tests, and the only place where a check engine light can keep a car off the road.

But Memphis City Councilwoman Wanda Halbert pointed out, "Memphians aren't the only ones polluting this air."

Maybe not, but the new tests are only in Memphis. And if your check engine light on, you fail.

Councilwoman Janis Fulliove told abc24.com, "I have had so many calls from people unable to pass inspection because their engine light will not go off."

It's not fair, says Councilman Lee Harris, and it is keeping people struggling for every dollar off the road.

"People shouldn't have to go traveling around town to get that engine light checked out. I don't like that," he said.

This issue is picking up steam because so many of you are steamed. Council members have been told there's nothing they can do, but they'll meet in several weeks to see if that's true.

Share
7 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of abc24 News

granni72 - 3/23/2012 2:19 AM
0 Votes
i notice a lot of people living in Memphis (illegally) with Mississippi plates Im looking out my window at 4 different Suvs parked at this apartment every night no license/insurance/and going to Mississippi to get plates when the rest of us seem to be paying the price.

gma22 - 3/1/2012 1:45 PM
0 Votes
Frankly this whole inspection thing is assinine. I mean, does that mean if you drive over to the county the air is no longer dirty or drive just across either state line? Ridiculous!!! That nitwit Hooks can spout off all she wants about federal this or that, but the FEDS are not forcing the inspections in the first place or the surrounding areas would have to have them too. I have no problem with the inspections but they should be for Shelby county as a whole not just Memphis city limits. On top of that, this check engine light thing is a horses patoot. We had a grand marquis that we had worked on at least 6 times because the light would not stay off. We had sensors replaced and emissions checked (which by the way, the emissions always passed with flying colors at inspections) and we never did get that thing to stay off so it is just another way to hassle people.

memphoman - 2/22/2012 11:29 AM
0 Votes
It's really not fair the city residents once again bare a tax burden based on somethig shared by Shelby and the surounding counties and states. This law is a nightmare, I've experienced first-hand. Either it passes emissions (that's pollution, Ms Hooks) or not! Most city residents don't come close to Janet Hooks salary, and struggle everyday to put gas in their cars, so they can put food on the table. This is going to eat our local economy alive. I predict it will end up in court. I would love to know more about the process, people, and companies involved in the sell and integration of this new system--I bet there's a worthy new story in there somewhere. Maybe Ms Hooks should look up from her bubble, and look around to see where all this pollution is really coming from--unregulated business, vehicles, plants, and a few politicians mouths. I could see a solution, perhaps where the car is passed as long as it passes the tailpipe test. Then, are given the next year to get that fixed, and be formally tested regardless the following year. This way people have time to troubleshoot, and people can sell/buy cars, and move on with their lives. As it stands, This hurts Memphians, and is not the solution to the pollution in our air.

memphoman - 2/22/2012 11:29 AM
1 Vote
It's really not fair the city residents once again bare a tax burden based on somethig shared by Shelby and the surounding counties and states. This law is a nightmare, I've experienced first-hand. Either it passes emissions (that's pollution, Ms Hooks) or not! Most city residents don't come close to Janet Hooks salary, and struggle everyday to put gas in their cars, so they can put food on the table. This is going to eat our local economy alive. I predict it will end up in court. I would love to know more about the process, people, and companies involved in the sell and integration of this new system--I bet there's a worthy new story in there somewhere. Maybe Ms Hooks should look up from her bubble, and look around to see where all this pollution is really coming from--unregulated business, vehicles, plants, and a few politicians mouths. I could see a solution, perhaps where the car is passed as long as it passes the tailpipe test. Then, are given the next year to get that fixed, and be formally tested regardless the following year. This way people have time to troubleshoot, and people can sell/buy cars, and move on with their lives. As it stands, This hurts Memphians, and is not the solution to the pollution in our air.

Reasonable Man - 2/22/2012 8:10 AM
0 Votes
Taking the bulb out will not do any good. The computer has a fault registered and it will not let go of it until the problem is fixed and the fault cycles through a series of tests by the computer and passes them. I ended up having to buy another work van because my van had an issue. I am in the real estate industry and I could not afford to buy another van but I HAD to because of this STUPID law. Funny thing my old van was a super low emmisions vehicle and did not produce more than the allowed amount of CO when tested through the tailpipe. This is a horrible thing to throw on people when the economy is so bad. SHAME on the government for making people spend so much money to fix their cars just because they live in Memphis. People who come her with a check engine light on should be ticketed when pulled over. That would make it fair to everyone. I will be sure to let my vote count against the people who made me buy another van when the other one seemed to run fine but had a stupid light on.

Frayserboi - 2/21/2012 6:55 PM
2 Votes
Well DUH, just take the fuse out for the light.....problem solved!

bdrjdc - 2/21/2012 6:31 PM
1 Vote
I don't think you should fail inspection because of a check engine light. I had a car once that they replaced the computer, the wiring, everything and the dang light would not go out. No problems with the car...just the stupid light. I think there are alot more things polluting our cities other than cars with check engine lights shining!! Like meth labs, dirty needles in the streets, etc. Let these cars through. So glad I don't live in Memphis anymore!!
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.