Flood Warning expires at 9:47 AM on 5/30, issued at 9:47 AM Alamo, TN | Bells, TN | Bogota, TN | Crockett Mills, TN

Mississippi Teen Charged with Murder for Hit & Run

Reported by: Shelley Orman
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 7/23/2012 6:48 pm
COMO, MS (abc24.com) - Deputies say a 61-year-old Mississippi man was intentionally hit and killed while walking on the side of the road in Panola County on Sunday, July 22.

17-year-old Matthew Whitten Darby is charged with his murder. Investigators say Darby purposefully ran down John Butts, possibly for the color of his skin.

Butts was a cancer survivor and Sunday school teacher. He liked to exercise before church. His family says Butts always stayed well away from traffic. Investigators tell us that didn't matter yesterday.

"The car came over purposely to hit him," says the victim's sister, Patricia Jones. "When John walked he was all the way on the opposite side. He didn't get in the street. He wasn't by anyone. They came off the road -- that's what gets me."

John Butts died on Highway 310 in Como. A few orange markings show the spot he was hit around seven Sunday morning.

"They left him," Jones says. "They just ran over him like he was roadkill in the street and kept going."

Investigators say a car of three white teenage boys ran Butts down. Darby was driving.

"From what we know right now it does look like an intentional act," District Attorney John Champion tells abc24.com.

Darby was arrested after a tip.

As for why Butts was hit, and if race was a motive, "That's something we're looking at. We're not ruling anything out on that right now," Champion says.

For Butts' family, the "why" will come later. Right now their loss is too hard to comprehend.

In 2006 they say Butts was hit by a train. He broke his neck and while in the hospital doctors discovered he had colon cancer.

"He survived all of that six years and two months ago," Jones says. "(Sunday) he was walking to better himself to get healthy," Jones says. "He'd lost so much weight. By him exercising to lose weight it cost him his life."

"The relief will come when justice is done," adds his other sister Linda Jones. "We know his soul is with the Lord, but justice has to be done."

Darby is being held at the Panola County Jail. The teen is facing a life sentence.

Both he and one of his two passengers, a 15-year-old, have also both been charged with burglary of a church. Investigators say they committed that crime before the hit and run.

The other teen in the car has not been charged.

Share
25 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of abc24 News

itisntright - 11/6/2012 9:32 PM
0 Votes
i am the fifteen year old boy now sixteen saying that it was not just bad for the butts family... this affected my life majorly because what alot of people didnt know is that we did get out of the car to see if he was alright, seeing a motionless body after he came through the window wasnt the best thing in the world for us to see. it was almost like reaction to get in the car and drive off even though it wasnt right. now one of my best friends is in jail and i have images in my head that will never go away and sometimes i just want to say sorry a million times to the butts family but cant because im afraid they will kill me. and i can not blame them cause i had my dad recently pass away and i know how it can hurt. i wanted to let the butts family know that i saw the whole thing and i was there and most importantly we did not plan it out to do anything like that that night. and it was not because he was black because we had more friends that were colored than u can count... it was a brutal thing and i dont know how im going to tell my daughter that was actually recently borin in october... it was a scary morning wen john butts was killed because i thought i would never see my daughter and never live a regular teenage life again...

itisntright - 11/6/2012 9:31 PM
0 Votes
i am the fifteen year old boy now sixteen saying that it was not just bad for the butts family... this affected my life majorly because what alot of people didnt know is that we did get out of the car to see if he was alright, seeing a motionless body after he came through the window wasnt the best thing in the world for us to see. it was almost like reaction to get in the car and drive off even though it wasnt right. now one of my best friends is in jail and i have images in my head that will never go away and sometimes i just want to say sorry a million times to the butts family but cant because im afraid they will kill me. and i can not blame them cause i had my dad recently pass away and i know how it can hurt. i wanted to let the butts family know that i saw the whole thing and i was there and most importantly we did not plan it out to do anything like that that night. and it was not because he was black because we had more friends that were colored than u can count... it was a brutal thing and i dont know how im going to tell my daughter that was actually recently borin in october... it was a scary morning wen john butts was killed because i thought i would never see my daughter and never live a regular teenage life again...

itisntright - 11/6/2012 9:20 PM
0 Votes
i

md2012 - 8/9/2012 2:11 AM
0 Votes
It was an AWFUL accident & I feel horrible for the Butts family..but the fact that the media is calling it a hate crime is absurd! JUST bc the boy was white & the victim was black. Whit Darby is NO racist & YES he made a mistake that will forever affect his life. He should have stopped but keep in mind he is a young kid & I'm sure he was scared to death. The media will make even the best people look like the devil.. but you should keep both families in your prayers and STOP trying to be God & judge w/out knowing anything about Darby or what REALLY happened. God is the only one who has that right & he is a very forgiving God.

JeffersonTao - 7/31/2012 5:44 PM
1 Vote
"Wide set eyes, Long, sloping nozzle." "In Midtown....surely they will be serving fruit & nuts!" "if it quacks like a duck, call a spade a spade" "Wide-set, beady eyes; Long sloping nozzle; ears like Obamma's.....typical profile...." "I have never understood why most minorities don't know how to swim, although I think I have read somewhere where thier bones are denser, thus making the body less buoyant." "Will they have an "x" at the spot on the balcony where King enjoyed his post-coital cigarette???" "did anyone else notice that "Tamika's" nozzle is wider than her mouth???" ALL ARE QUOTES FROM THE "NON-RACIST" FRAYSERRBOI. I SUPPOSE ADOLF HITLER WAS NO RACIST EITHER.

proudmomof2 - 7/26/2012 9:16 AM
1 Vote
FRAYSERBOI...you must be related to these "Innocent" boys. 3 teenagers out on an EARLY Sunday morning demaging things!!! They have the 17 yr old car with demage headlights,windsheild, hood and blood on it. They "INNOCENT".....give me a break. WHY did this Darby kid go across to the OTHER lane and hit that man???? AGAIN ALL 3 should have been heading to CHURCH instead of demaging one and running an INNOCENT MAN OVER!!!! Why did Darby leave the scene?? hide his car?? OH because he's INNOCENT!! YES, both families are hurting. But you have to realize that the BUTTS family lost their loved because a teenager thought it would be OK to CROSS the lane and hit that old man for NO reason. We all have our OWN OPINION on things. But we realize we are NOT the judge/jury! AND YES I'M STILL GOING TO BE A PROUD MOM OF 2 AND A WIFE. HAVE A GREAT DAY b/c I sure am:)

Frayserboi - 7/26/2012 3:36 AM
1 Vote
So proud we have such educated, enlightened & inspiring citizens such as "proudmomof2" to serve as judge, jury & executioner....LOL..would someone PLEASE clue her into the concept of innocent until proven guilty? Where is the compassion for these possibly totally innocent youths?

proudmomof2 - 7/25/2012 10:41 PM
1 Vote
This young guiy needs to be in jail for a LONG time. I hope they dont give him a bond..if so it needs to 1million cash ONLY!!! Darby should have been heading to church instead of demaging one. He problably was HIGH on drugs!!!!

Frayserboi - 7/24/2012 7:07 PM
1 Vote
I calls 'em as I sees 'em....NOTHING I have posted has been RACIAL in ANY way.....some of these poster's need to ask forgiveness, and that boy, "orangevol", has been reported!

Frayserboi - 7/24/2012 6:56 PM
1 Vote
That evil, racist train jumped right offen the tracks & ran down that man....it's a hate crime & we should BAN all trains....LOL
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.